HMRC Refused Time To Pay? What Happens Next

If HMRC has refused your company’s Time to Pay proposal, you may be worried about what happens next. Can the business continue trading? Could HMRC take further action? Does the company need to consider liquidation?
A refusal does not automatically mean the business must close. But it does mean directors need to review the financial position promptly and decide what the company can realistically afford.
Start by understanding why HMRC refused the proposal, checking any enforcement deadlines and updating the company’s cash-flow forecast. If another affordable proposal is not possible, there may be other rescue or closure options.
The important thing is not to ignore the refusal or make promises the company cannot keep.
1. Find out why HMRC refused the proposal
Keep HMRC’s letter or email and a note of any telephone conversations. Check the type and amount of tax owed, the periods covered, interest, outstanding returns and any response deadline.
Ask HMRC why the proposal was rejected. Was the monthly payment too low? Was the cash-flow forecast unclear? Or was the company unable to show how it would pay new tax bills?
If the tax balance is disputed, identify the figures you disagree with and raise them with HMRC and your accountant. Challenging the amount owed is different from asking for more time to pay an agreed debt.
Ask whether HMRC has started or intends to start recovery action. If you have received a summary warrant, correspondence from sheriff officers, notice of arrestment or a winding-up petition, seek advice immediately. The next steps depend on the documents and stage of proceedings.
2. Work out what the company can genuinely afford
Prepare a realistic cash-flow forecast covering at least the next 13 weeks. This is a useful management exercise, not a fixed HMRC requirement.
Include the current bank balance, reliable customer receipts, wages, rent, essential suppliers, finance commitments, the cost of completing existing orders and tax due on its actual payment dates.
Show historic HMRC arrears separately from new VAT, PAYE and Corporation Tax. Identify uncertain receipts and consider what happens if a major customer pays late.
There are two important questions to answer:
- Can the company make affordable payments towards its existing tax arrears?
- Can it also pay its ongoing tax liabilities and trading costs as they fall due?
HMRC’s published Time to Pay principles require it to be satisfied on both points. Any applicable late-payment interest also needs to be included.
If the shortfall is temporary, identify what will resolve it and when. If the company is continuing to lose money through normal trading, spreading its tax arrears over more months may only make the problem worse.
3. Review directors’ duties before taking on further commitments
Bring the directors together to review the cash-flow forecast, bank statements, tax correspondence, creditor balances and current order book.
Keep a record of the assumptions considered, decisions made, professional advice received and the date of the next review.
HMRC refusing Time to Pay does not, by itself, mean the company is insolvent or that trading must stop.
However, where a company is insolvent or approaching insolvency, directors must consider the interests of creditors. The significance of those interests depends on the company’s financial circumstances and the likelihood of insolvent liquidation or administration.
Before accepting new orders, taking customer deposits, obtaining further supplier credit or transferring assets, directors should consider whether the company can meet the resulting obligations.
If there is a risk that continued trading could worsen the position for creditors, it is important to seek professional insolvency advice promptly.
4. Could HMRC accept a revised Time to Pay proposal?
It may be worth speaking to HMRC again if the original proposal was based on incomplete information or the company’s circumstances have materially improved.
A revised proposal should clearly explain the amount owed, where the proposed payments will come from, when they can be made and how the company will keep up with new tax liabilities.
HMRC considers Time to Pay proposals individually and is not obliged to accept an arrangement.
Its guidance says that arrangements should generally be for the shortest period the taxpayer can reasonably afford. For businesses, arrangements lasting more than 12 months are exceptional. Interest may also continue to accrue.
Remember that discussing a proposal with HMRC does not mean an arrangement has been agreed. Do not assume that recovery action has stopped unless HMRC has confirmed the position.
For more information, read our HMRC Time to Pay guide.
5. What if another payment arrangement is not realistic?
If the business is fundamentally viable and the cash-flow problem can be resolved, there may still be options to help it recover.
Depending on the circumstances, these could include informal agreements with creditors, additional funding or a formal restructuring procedure.
A Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) may allow a company to reach a formal agreement with its creditors to repay or compromise its debts, subject to the statutory process and necessary approvals.
Administration may be appropriate in some circumstances, particularly where there is a viable business or sale to protect and one of the statutory purposes of administration can be achieved.
However, neither procedure will make an unaffordable trading plan viable on its own.
If there is no realistic prospect of recovery, a Scottish Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL) may provide an orderly way to close the company and deal with its outstanding affairs.
The right option will depend on the company’s assets, employees, secured creditors, existing creditor action and available funding.
It is important to understand the likely costs and consequences of each option before deciding how to proceed.
You can find out more about business rescue and restructuring options or read our guide to Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation in Scotland.
Questions directors often ask
Does HMRC refusing Time to Pay mean we must stop trading immediately?
No. There is no automatic requirement to stop trading simply because HMRC has refused a Time to Pay proposal.
However, directors must assess the company’s financial position, whether it can continue meeting its obligations and whether any urgent creditor action is taking place.
If insolvency is a possibility, professional advice should be obtained promptly.
Can we make another Time to Pay offer?
Yes. You can ask HMRC to reconsider, particularly if you can correct information in the original proposal or demonstrate a genuine change in circumstances.
HMRC does not have to accept another proposal, and any revised offer must be affordable alongside new tax liabilities and the company’s ongoing trading costs.
Should we pay HMRC ahead of other creditors?
Paying HMRC ahead of other creditors is not automatically prohibited.
However, where insolvency is a concern, directors should carefully consider the purpose and consequences of payments, including their effect on creditors generally.
Scottish insolvency law contains specific rules on unfair preferences, including exceptions for certain payments of debts that are already due.
Payments to connected parties and unusual transactions require particular care.
If you are uncertain which creditors should be paid, seek professional advice before making significant or selective payments.
HMRC Refused Time to Pay?
If HMRC has refused your company’s Time to Pay proposal, it can be difficult to know what to do next.
At Lennox Insolvency, we help directors of Scottish companies understand their options when tax arrears and creditor pressure become difficult to manage.
We can review the company’s financial position, help assess whether another payment proposal is realistic and explain the alternatives if the business can no longer afford to continue.
You don’t need to decide whether the company needs rescuing or liquidating before speaking to us.
Contact Lennox for a confidential discussion about your next steps.

Speak to Lennox
Tell us which payment or creditor action is most urgent and what the company can realistically collect. We can help you work through the immediate decisions and the available Scottish options.
